Aye, I'm finding EH to have produced some really nice analog effects stuff beyond the distortion/overdrive type. Fuzz really isn't my thing, so that cuts out a lot of those bizarrely named boutique types.
I'm less excited than I was about building an overdrive pedal, since it just makes more sense now to buy a really good overdrive and then build something a little less integral to my tone, like a volume pedal to start.
I've found The Comparinator, which I feel like I've already posted somewhere, which is another great resource for OD pedals. Most pedal shooutouts are poorly recorded and have ever-changing setups, but this guy studio-recorded a couple dozen pedals playing the exact same riffs in the exact same situation, and allows you to listen to them all side by side at different settings.
http://www.oldtonezone.com/distortionov ... parinator/I'm presently leaning towards a Maxon--OD9 Pro + or a couple others--or an Emma. Maybe a Xotic, but haven't heard enough of them.